Skip to main content
  • OLDE LIBRARY TAVERN logo top - Homepage
    OLDE LIBRARY TAVERN logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • Catering
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
OLDE LIBRARY TAVERN logo top - HomepageOLDE LIBRARY TAVERN logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • Catering

Our Menu

  • Menu

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions*

Appetizers

The Prologue Pair
$5.99

Classic ruffles served with our house sour cream & onion dip.

Chapter & Cheers Queso
$5.99

Crisp tortilla chips paired with Tavern queso and salsa.
Add savory chorizo +$2.00

Pig Tails
$12.99

Six single cut tavern ribs grilled, dusted and sauced, served with celery and carrot.

The Buffalo Edition
$8.99

A bubbling blend of buffalo chicken, cheese, and suspense- with tortilla chips.

The Bestseller Fries
$10.99

Tavern queso, cheese, and bacon on top of crispy fries with jalapeno and ranch drizz.

The Melting Plot
$10.99

Six crispy golden mozzarella planks, side of red sauce.

Tales of Tuscany
$11.99

Meatballs and Italian sausage in red sauce with garlic bread.

Page Turners
$9.99

Tavern garlic, cheese breadsticks served with red sauce.

Bookfold WV Pepp Roll
$10.99

Pepperoni and cheese folded in like a well-worn novel with red sauce.

Plotstickers
$10.99

Sometimes known as potstickers with our Tavern-made sticker sauce.

The Scarlet Shrimp
$10.99

Six Buffalo shrimp that will leave its mark, celery and carrot sticks with ranch or bleu.

Midnight Ink Tuna Bites
$11.99

Blackened ahi tuna bites served with Tavern-made tartar sauce.

Of Pigs and Pages
$10.99

Crispy pork belly with blazed brussel sprouts and balsamic glaze drizzle.

The Stacked Story Nachos
$11.99

Queso, chili, jalapeños, crema drizzle on crispy tortilla chips, side of salsa.

Golden Plot Twist
$11.99

Three soft pretzels served with Tavern queso and spicy mustard.

The Sweet Potato Files
$9.99

Sweet potato waffle fries served with a side of hot honey ricotta dip.

Wings

*Tavern Style Traditional & Editors Cut Boneless*

Wings

10.00$ (6) | 20.00$ (12) | 30.00$ (18) | 40.00$ (24)
One Ranch or Bleu and Celery per 6 count
Celery and Carrots

SAUCED

Bright Lights Edition -XXX
Hogdilly’s Hot Chapter -XX
Jammin’ Tale Gold-XX
Smoldering BBQ -X
Hot Dracula Parmesan - X
Buffalo Cajun Badboys-X
Nashville Hot Honey Manuscript -X
Golden Chapter
BBQ Chronicle
Library Buffalo
Library Buffalo Lemon Pepper
Korean Tavern Sticker
Garlic Parmesan Page

DRY

Cajun Bookmark
Lemon Pepper Leaf
Tavern Dust
Nashville Novel
Italian Index

Soups

+ Grilled cheese $2.50

Almost-Famous Chili
$5.99/Bowl
The Tomato Tale
$5.99/Bowl
Hot off the Press
$5.99/Bowl

(Soup of the Month)

The Librarian’s Garden

The Pittsburgh Chapter

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Sirloin steak and crispy fries on top of fresh lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, and hot peppers, topped with shredded cheddar blend.

The Buffalo Edition (Fried or Grilled)

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Breaded or grilled chicken breast tossed in choice of wing sauce, served over lettuce with fries on top, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, and hot peppers, finished with shredded cheddar blend.

Tavern Club

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Turkey, ham, bacon, egg, tomatoes, cheddar jack, on crisp salad greens.

The Southwest Story

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Grilled chicken on top of romaine, corn pico, tomatoes, cheddar blend, topped with tortilla crisps and housemade Aztec ranch.

The Caesar Manuscript

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Breaded or grilled chicken breast over romaine, tossed with croutons, tomatoes, Caesar dressing, and parmesan.

The Italian Archive (Antipasto Salad)

Half $8.99 | Full $14.99
Ham, salami, pepperoni provolone and mozzarella blend, over lettuce with tomatoes, red onions, and hot peppers served with Tavern vinaigrette.

SALAD ADD ONS

Extra Dressing $0.99
Egg $1.25
Bacon $1.25
Cheese $1.25
French Fries $1.99
Chicken $4.50
Steak $5.50

DRESSINGS

Tavern-made Ranch, Italian, Honey Mustard, Bleu Cheese, Tavern-made Vinaigrette, French, Caesar, Tavern-made Aztec Ranch, & Balsamic Vinaigrette

Bookmark Side Salads

Tavern House
$4.99

Fresh lettuce, cheese blend, tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives and Tavern vinaigrette.

Cut Wedge
$4.99

Cut iceberg, bacon, tomatoes, red onion, blue ranch w/ bleu cheese crumbles & balsamic.

Julius Caesar
$4.99

Romaine, tossed with croutons, tomatoes, parmesan and Caesar dressing.

Bash Brothers Burgers

¼ Bash Burger Served with chips and pickles
Add ¼ Bash Patty $3.50 | Add LTO $0.00 | Chip Dip $1.99
*GF Bun available

The First Edition
$9.99

Standard cheeseburger. Egg or crispy bacon $1.50

Rocket’s Double Feature
$14.99

Two patties stacked with white Cooper Sharp, crispy bacon, ketchup and mayonaiase.

J-Dorado
$12.99

Pepper Jack, tomatoes, crispy onions, spinach, garlic parmesan and Tavern sticker sauce drizzle.

Outlaw Josie Wales
$12.99

Almost Famous chili, Tavern queso and fried onions.

Southern Tale
$12.99

Pimento cheese, bacon jam with red onion.

Murph’s Spicy Romance
$12.99

White Cooper Sharp, grilled jalapeños, fried onion with chipotle aioli.

Once Upon a Sub

Served with chips and pickles
Add LTO, Wrap a 6"
*Additional Toppings $1.50
*Extra Meat $3.50

The Twain Cheesesteak

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Steak, Cooper Sharp, all day onions.

The Poe Meatball Sub

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Meatballs, Provolone and mozzarella, parmesan and red sauce.

The Odyssey Big Dog

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Meatball, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Provolone and mozzarella, with red sauce.

The Dante Italian

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Ham, salami, pepperoni, Provolone and mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, Tavern vinaigrette.

The Chaucer Parm

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Chicken Parm, Provolone and mozzarella, parmesan, red sauce. Add pepperoni +$1.50

The Hawthorne Buffalo Chicken

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Fried or grilled chicken (choice of sauce), Cheddar blend with ranch or bleu.

The Fine Swine

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Ham, white Cooper Sharp, mayonnaise and LTO.
GO HAWAIIAN, Pineapple and Red Onion +$3.00

The Melville King Fish Sub

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Beer-battered fish, lettuce, cheese, tartar sauce.

The Whitman Club

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Turkey, ham, bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato, mayo.

The Orwell Pizza Sub

6" $10.00 | 12" $20.00
Pepperoni, sausage, provolone and mozzarella with red sauce.

Big Beef Dogs

Served with chips and pickles

The Foreword Frank
$5.00

Standard Weiner. Chilli $1.50

The West Virginia Chapter
$7.00

Chili, sauteed onions, mustard and slaw.

The Alchemist
$7.00

Bacon jam, Tavern relish, sauteed onions, ketchup and mustard, topped with chips.

House of Heat
$7.00

Chili, cheddar blend, jalapenos, sauteed onions, hot sauce, topped with tortilla chips.

The Italian Volume
$7.00

Italian sausage, green peppers, onions in red sauce.

Bookfolds

*Additional Toppings $1.50

The Hemingway Stromboli
$15.00

Ham, sausage, pepperoni, Provolone, mozzarella, banana peppers & red sauce.

Austen’s Ham & Cheese
$12.00

Warm ham with white Cooper Sharp cheese.
GO HAWAIIAN, Pineapple and Red Onion +$3.00

The Dickens Meatball Fold
$13.50

Meatballs, Provolone, mozzarella, parmesan and red sauce.

The Fitzgerald Cheesesteak
$13.50

Steak, white Cooper Sharp cheese, all day onions.

The Brontë Buffalo Chicken
$13.50

Grilled Buffalo chicken (choice of sauce), Cheddar blend, with ranch or bleu.

The Tolstoy Parm Fold
$13.50

Chicken parm, Provolone, mozzarella, parmesan, red sauce. Add pepperoni $1.50

The Homer Meatzza’primo
$15.00

Ham, salami, sausage, pepperoni, bacon, green peppers and onion.

Fit Fare

The Caesar Wrap Chapter
$12.99

Choice of grilled/ fried chicken, romaine, with croutons, tomatoes, parmesan and Caesar dressing with side.

The Low-Carb Legend
$12.99

No bun bash burger (choice of single) served with side salad choice.

Korean Power Page
$15.99

Choice of Korean grilled bulgogi beef or chicken, kimchi fried rice, broccoli and red onion.

Sides

French Fries
$2.99
Sweet Potato Fries
$2.99
Steamed Broccoli
$2.99
Brussels
$3.99
Bacon Cheese Fries
$3.99
Kimchi Fried Rice
$3.99
Side Salad Choice
$4.99
Slaw
$0.99

Tavern Pies

*GF Pie Available

The O.G.
$10.99

Mozzarella, provolone, red sauce.
B.Y.O.G Toppings $1.50 each

Hot Honey Plot Twist
$13.99

Cup & Char pepperoni, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan, red sauce, and hot honey drizzle.
Add Fried/ Grilled Chicken $1.50

Flyin’ Hawaiian
$13.99

Tavern ham, pineapple, red onion, red sauce with a honey soy drizzle.

BJ’s Steakhouse Chronicle
$13.99

Steak, sauteed onion, mushroom, mozzarella, provolone, Tavern garlic white sauce with horseradish dill cream drizzle.

White Quill Pie
$10.99

Tavern garlic white sauce, mozzarella, provolone and parmesan.
Add Fried/ Grilled Chicken $1.50

Golden Girl Edition
$13.99

Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar blend, red onion, BBQ-gold and ranch drizzle.

The Kung Fusion Manuscript -
$13.99

Korean grilled bulgogi beef, green pepper, red onion, white garlic sauce with Tavern sticker drizzle.

The Bleu Buffalo Anthology
$13.99

Buffalo chicken, ranch or bleu cheese, cheddar blend and ranch drizzle.

Jay’s 3-B Pie
$13.99

Jay’s signature burger sauce, bash burger, red onion, bacon, pickle, cheddar blend and signature drizzle.

The Hot Sausage Prologue
$13.99

Sausage, banana peppers, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan and red sauce.

The Meatzza Manifesto
$13.99

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, mozzarella, provolone, and red sauce.

Suprema House Collection
$13.99

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, banana peppers and red sauce.

Add:
$1.50

Pepperoni, Green Peppers, Hot Sausage, Mushrooms, Anchovies, Onions, Banana Peppers, Bacon, Black Olives, Ham, Red Onions, Meatballs, Spinach, Extra Cheese, Jalapeños, Tomatoes

Pasta

After 4PM
Served with Garlic Toast

Nunnie’s Baked Volume

Half $9.99 | Whole $15.99
Baked pasta with meatball, Italian sausage, provolone blend and parmesan with garlic toast.

The Blackened Chronicle

Half $9.99 | Whole $15.99
Blackened chicken and sausage Alfredo with garlic toast.

Speciality Dinners

Tavern Tenders
$15.99

A platter of six Tavern-made golden tenders served with fries and slaw.

Seaside Storybook Shrimp
$16.99

Eight fried shrimp with fries and slaw, straight from a Saltair chapter.

Fisherman’s Folio
$16.99

A whimsical fish-and-chips supper with slaw and tartar, inspired by old harbor tales.

Kids Menu

*Served with side and drink

The Very Hungry Grilled Cheese
$7.99

A warm, melty grilled cheese perfect for little ones ready to munch their way through the day.

The Magic Tree Tenders
$7.99

Two golden chicken tenders for explorers climbing into big adventures.

The Wizard’s Hot Dog
$7.99

A classic hot dog for young wizards and wandwavers everywhere.

The Cheesy Chronicles (Pizza)
$7.99

A bubbling cheese pie straight from a cozy cottage kitchen.

The Quesadilla in the Hat
$7.99

A cheddar-filled quesadilla folded neat and tidy, with sour cream on the side.

The Pasta Potion
$7.99

A bowl of spellbinding noodles - choose red sauce or Alfredo to complete the brew.

Desserts

*All Include one scoop of ice cream
Next scoop $1.50

Storybook Skillet Cookie
$9.99

Chocolate drizzle.

Brownie Epilogue
$9.99

Whipped cream, peanut butter drizzle.

Kami’s Factory New York Cheesecake
$9.99

Carmel or chocolate drizzle.

The Orange Dream Fable Cake
$9.99
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs